James White laughs at Dr. William Lane Craig

Dr. William Lane Craig’s analogy of the Trinity gets laughed at by James White

I almost never post youtube or any other videos, but I think this one is worth a place on Unveiling Christianity. Enjoy.

In summary:

Dr. William Lane Craig: The Trinity is like a three headed  dog from hell

Dr. James White : Bwahahahahahahahahaha

Incoming search terms:

  • james white william lane craig
  • william lane craig james white
  • william lane craig net worth
  • james white on william lane craig
  • william lane craig trinity
  • Dr James White on the Trinity
You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

23 Responses to “James White laughs at Dr. William Lane Craig”

  1. Aliyu Musa Misau says:

    I always feel deep remorse for all my fellow humans that have unconciously been brainwashed to believe in a theoretical concept of god whose identity (that he is a ‘trinity’) is not ‘revealed’ in their holy book (the Bible) as admitted by the mainstream trinitarian scholars themselves, and the language necessary to describe this god (3 persons in one being, 3 gods in one god etc) is never used of God in their holy book as also admitted by mainstream trinitarian scholars. I think that spiritual bondage is worse than physical bondage.

    • Boywonder23k says:

      I think it should stand out to everyone here that no one (including “Dr.” White) actually gave any sort of substantial reason why Dr. Craig’s analogy breaks down. All that has been said both in the comments and by Mr. White is “can you believe that! He compared the Trinity to a pagan myth! That’s not bIblical!” What Craig is attempting to do is to show that the notion of 3 in 1 is not an illogical absurdity. The analogy he uses (although not flattering) is legitimate in so far as it accomplishes that goal. He is obviously not saying that the Trinity is a 3 headed dog guarding the gates of hell. Unless someone can give a scripture or some other logical reason why that isn’t a good analogy his scholarship remains leaps and bounds ahead of the competition.

      I think that dr. Craig would agree that there really isn’t any kind of analogy that
      Can FULLY encompass the Trinity. That does not mean however that the ONLY possible answer to that question is “no one can ever know anything about the trinity because God is unique”. Craig gave a good answer and this video serves as another illustration of”Dr.” Whites arrogance and sub par professionalism. You don’t get invited to big conferences because you aren’t a respected scholar. It has nothing to do with you “loose canon” unprofessionalism.

  2. Marwan says:

    Salamu alaikum bro

    I’m glad you enjoyed the video 🙂

  3. The Bull says:

    Dr. William Craig is an evolutionist and so is going to have a distorted view of God. It is an absurd analogy and would be laughable if it wasn’t so crude. The trinity cannot be compared with a three headed dog that protects hell?!? The man should be reprimanded.

  4. Dr.Mustafa says:

    WHAT MARTIN LUTHER SAYS ABOUT TRINITY

    1)It is indeed true that the name “Trinity” is nowhere to be found in the Holy Scriptures, but has been conceived and invented by man. For this reason it sounds somewhat cold and we had better speak of “God” than of the “Trinity.”

    2)This word signifies that there are three persons in God. It is a heavenly mystery which the world cannot understand

    3)The great universities have invented manifold distinctions, dreams and fictions by means of which they would explain the Holy Trinity, and have made fools of themselves

    (Martin Luther, “Sunday After Pentecost, or Trinity Sunday”, in Sermons of Martin Luther, vol. 3, edited and translated by John Nicholas Lenker, Baker Book House reprint (n.d.) of The Precious and Sacred Writings of Martin Luther, 1907 edition, vol. 12, pp. 406-407 )

  5. Dr.Mustafa says:

    TRINITY AND LOGIC

    Christians usually say that father,son and holy spirit are three distinct persons and each one is God but they say their is only one God an out and out logical absurdity.

    What i want to tell here is that if 3 distinct entities are not 3 entities but only 1 entity then the same can be said for entities which are more that 3 and for 2 entities.

    With this i will show what happens when this logic is applied to other things , as iam a doctor i will show what happens if we apply this logic to human body

    TRINITY AND HUMAN BODY

    We have 2 testicles(balls) both develop at the same time ,from same part in the body ,both have same structure and function.So with the logic of Christians we should say humans have 2 distinct balls but their is only 1 ball !

    We have 2 eyes ,2 ears 2 hands 2 legs but with logic of Christians we should say humans have only 1 eye ,1ear and 1 hand !

    As i said this logic can also be applied to more than 3 entities why only 3
    Humans have 10 fingers ,32 teeth ,many hair,many organs,innumerable cells but with the Christian logic their is only 1 finger,1 teeth,1 hair ,1 organ and only 1 cell in human body !

    • MilkyDud says:

      If you assume the trinity is contradiction, please present the evidence.

      The law of non contradiction is…
      *A* can not be*A* and non*A* at the same time and in the same relationship.

      The trinity states…
      God is one in *A* essence/existence/being
      And Three in *B* person/subsistence

      While the Muslims insist it is not a contradiction, it is not, but as make clear by Dr Mustafa does misunderstand the trinity formula, its logic, its laws/science.

      Now, if Islam is true, it would be honest and at least present the trinity accurately, but I assume the Muslims logic comes from a book that also inaccuracy depicts the trinity formula.

    • Jason says:

      So Jesus is a three headed dog. You can’t compare a God with those myth crap!!!

  6. Dr.Mustafa says:

    Trinity is indeed a contradiction and as for your evidence i have given an example above how the christian understanding of trinity looks if applied to human body.

    You tried to explain the trinity and made a fool of yourself according to Martin Luther just like William Lane Craig

    You said
    God is one in *A* essence/existence/being
    And Three in *B* person/subsistence

    Let us apply this to human body again
    Testicles are one in essence/existence/being as both develop at the same time ,from same part in the body ,both have same structure and function bit 2 in person.So according to the trinitarian logic there is only 1 testicle in human body.Same thing can be applied to other things not even in the human body but also to other things in the universe

    Plus the Quran perfectly describes the trinity .It is you Christians who say Quran is wrong as when you say it is wright it will automatically knock out your contradictory and illogical faith

    • MilkyDud says:

      AGAIN…

      God is one in *A* essence/existence/being
      And Three in *B* person/subsistence

      Did you watch/listen to any of the links I sent you?

      ISSUE WITH YOUR EXAMPLES?Existence and Subsistence have NO DISTINCTIONS of differences.

      1)Does a three-leaf clover really have three leaves or one. If someone says three, you can point to the one leaf, because they are all connected in the middle. If someone says one, you can point to the three distinct lobes. In a similar manner, the Father, Son, and Spirit are distinct and yet inseparable.

      And WHERE in the QURAN is it an ACCURATE discription of Christian beliefs

      • Dr.Mustafa says:

        Again you have not read my points but just arguing illogically .

        Coming to your contention God is one in essence /existence/being but 3 in person/subsistence , the questions and the problems which arise for this contention are

        1)If God is 3 persons how come he is only 1 being?
        2)If God is 3 in subsistence how come he is only 1 in existence?
        3)If God is 1 being how come he is 3 persons?
        4)If God is 1 in existence how come he is 3 in persons?

        You also said God is 3 persons then how come God is 1 God ,there should be 3 Gods !

        My examples are perfect in your line of argument .Let us see again.The testicles are 1 in essence but 2 in person.Fingers of our hand and foot are 1 in essence but 10 in person.So there is only 1 testicle and 1 finger in humans according to the logic of trinity which the Christians use

        You tried to explain trinity by giving an example of clover leaf but it does not correspond to trinity .Clover leaf is a single leaf with 3 parts arising due to clove in it but the trinitarian concept of God is he is 3 different persons altogether not 1 person with 3 parts .The irony about your example is that you yourself said that it can be argued to be 3 or 1 .That is trinity you yourself doesn’t know is it 3 or 1.

        Again you made a fool of yourself by trying to explain the trinity according to Martin Luther the iconic figure of protestianism and ending up giving a wrong example that too!

        Plus there are 4 clover leaves ,5 and many clover-leaf leaves and this can be an example according to your logic to the Hindu understanding of God who say there are many Gods in person but 1 God in essence !.

        Coming onto the Quranic description of trinity can you show me where it is wrong in depicting it because you are the one who first claimed it to be wrong.

        Then coming on to your understanding of trinity , that is
        God is one in *A* essence/existence/being
        And Three in *B* person/subsistence

        I challenge you to produce a single verse which says this about God in the Bible and if you cant then that means the Bible itself never depicts trinity correctly !

        • André says:

          “My examples are perfect in your line of argument .Let us see again.The testicles are 1 in essence but 2 in person.Fingers of our hand and foot are 1 in essence but 10 in person.So there is only 1 testicle and 1 finger in humans according to the logic of trinity which the Christians use”

          You argument fails completely, committing the fallacy of ambiguity. The real conclusion from you argument is:
          “The testicles are 1 in essence but 2 in person.Fingers of our hand and foot are 1 in essence but 10 in person.So there is only 1 testicle-essence and 1 hand-essence in humans according to the logic of trinity which the Christians use.” Yes that is correct, what is the problem?

          But I am not surprised this is usually the case, Muslims all the time use straw men when they try to critizise christianity. Have not God taught you to treat your fellow-humans with respect. Is it that difficult for you to make an effort to understand what you are talking about?

          • Ibn Anwar says:

            The problem is quite clear for any thinking individual Andre. In the example of the testicles, you have two testicles and each are known as testicles and counted as TWO and NOT one. In the Trinity you have three persons and each are called GOD yet they are not counted as three Gods but one. If anyone is committing the fallacy of ambiguity and equivocation it is the Trinitarian.

          • André says:

            What you have in the example of testicles are *two testicles* but “one testicle-essence* (that which defines that each testicle is what it is as such), likewise in the Trinity you have three persons but one *essence*, divinity. No contradiction, no equivocation. And Yes Ibn Anwar, it should be be clear for any thinking individual, but obviously not to you. If God was not a trinity God would not be perfect love because to love is to love *somebody*. There is always perfect timeless love within the Godhead before creation of angels and the world. Therefore Allah cannot be God becuase he cannot be perfect love.

          • Ibn Anwar says:

            Thank you for sharing with us your view that your god is comparable to testicles, bravo.

          • REG says:

            define PERSON

            how many persons are speaking when god says

            ” i am god, there is no one besides me”

            ” If God was not a trinity God would not be perfect love because to love is to love *somebody*.”

            when he is a COMPLETE god is he still perfectly loving as an ” i ” ” me ”

            ” he ” and “him” ?

            or does “perfectly love” only when he DOES NOT speak as an ” i ” ” me ” ?

          • edris says:

            ” If God was not a trinity God would not be perfect love because to love is to love *somebody*. There is always perfect timeless love within the Godhead before creation of angels and the world. Therefore Allah cannot be God becuase he cannot be perfect ”

            this is like a man telling his wife , “i love you, but i don’t love you as a whole/your body”

            i can’t believe you likened your god to testicles.

  7. rocko says:

    you worship 3 gods mate. let me make it is easy for you. 3 evil spirits which possess ONE BODY have 3 SEPERATE wills. trinity gods have 3 minds/wills , they ask each other questions just like the hindu gods. so if 3 minds possessed one body does that MEAN 1 MIND? what kind of logic is that? even if you SUPERGLUED 3 spirits together and placed them in 1 body they would still be 3 SEPERATE beings. jezuos is not the trinity god. the 3 persons have to be together to be called the trinity god. jesus is a seperate god from the trinity god lol

  8. rocko says:

    “God is one in *A* essence/existence/being
    And Three in *B* person/subsistence”

    cut the crap about essense substance and replace them with words such as INGREDIENTS / MAKE UP

    then lets discuss

    so when god says i me him

    he is refering to three me’s three him’s and three i’s?

    the truth is the pagan gods u worship are not one, they are 3 seperate and independant gods which have same ingredient/make up/ essense / build. all you got to do is INVENT THE idea that all 3 gods AGREE and then u get a trinity.

    the father APPLIES his full wrath on the sons . in all honest minds the son has to be SEPERATE individual who also have divine qualities . so the son who have the same powers as the father is punsihed by the father . 2 SEPERATE beings. 2 seperate gods .one asking the other ” do me over” lol

  9. defendchrist says:

    hi where is the Trinity as believed by Christians rejected in the koran namely Father,the Son and the Holy Ghost which Jesus in Matthew 28?

  10. Deus Vult says:

    James White is your typical brainwashed “evangelical” who expects people to be “Christian” as a result of being browbeaten into submission by what? His “charming” personality.

    White is just your typical blowhard Churchian.

  11. Steve Schlichter says:

    I noticed that he never explained why it is a bad analogy.

Leave a Reply